Honorable Mentions
So, we’ve talked about the top-notch sleeping pads that really impressed us, but what about the ones that didn’t quite make the cut? Well, here are a few honorable mentions that might still be worth considering if none of the others catch your eye.
Kelty Kush Queen Airbed for $100
First up, we have the Kelty Kush Queen Airbed, coming in at a reasonable $100. This PVC-free queen-sized airbed includes a handy pump for easy inflation (just make sure you charge it up before heading out). The 6-inch-thick pad offers plenty of comfort, though it’s worth noting that this is not an insulated air mattress like some of the others we’ve mentioned. It’s best suited for warmer months, but it can also double as a spare bed at home if needed.
Sleeping Pads to Avoid
Now, let’s talk about the sleeping pads that didn’t quite meet our expectations. We’ve put these models to the test and encountered some issues along the way.
Exped Flexmat Plus
Ever wondered what it would be like if those classic closed-cell foam mats were super-sized? Well, the Exped Flexmat Plus attempts to answer that question, but falls short of the mark. This extra-thick, 1.5-inch mat is relatively light, cheap, and durable, but the foam itself is hard and spikey. And when we say spikey, we mean it literally has spikes that can make for a rather uncomfortable night’s sleep. Some fans suggest a break-in period, but after six nights, reviewer Martin Cizmar was ready to call it quits.
Big Agnes Q-Core
Next up, we have the Big Agnes Q-Core, a pad that initially seems comfortable and boasts impressive R-value and weight stats for the price. However, we advise steering clear of this one. The unique offset I-beam construction that makes it lightweight and cozy also has a reputation for failing. Cizmar found this out the hard way after about a year of use, with the welds holding the top and bottom together coming apart. No amount of duct tape could fix the resulting lump that formed after adding air.
Exped DeepSleep
Considering an inflatable pad from Exped but not ready to splurge on the MegaMat 10? You might be tempted by the thinner and cheaper DeepSleep, but we urge you to think again. While it’s 3 inches thick instead of 4, that missing inch can make a big difference in comfort. The DeepSleep features rugged fabric on top and bottom, lacking the softness and stretchiness found in other models. While it may be suitable for some, it’s not quite the Exped experience most sleepers are after. Stick with the MegaMat for a better night’s rest.
Klymit Static V2
Lastly, we have the Klymit Static V2, a budget-friendly inflatable pad that’s popular among casual campers due to its low price point and lightweight design. I actually bought one for my daughter’s first backcountry trip, and while she didn’t complain, I found it to be rather flimsy. Offering minimal cushion and less heat retention compared to closed-cell foam pads, it may not be the best choice for everyone. The Z-Lite, for example, weighs slightly less and is less prone to punctures, providing a more reliable option in the long run.
So, there you have it – a rundown of some sleeping pads that didn’t quite make the cut. Remember, while these may not be our top picks, they could still be worth considering depending on your needs and preferences. Whether you’re looking for a budget-friendly option or a spare bed for guests, there’s something out there for everyone.
